Keegan takes on the case of three Amish bakers accused of attempted murder. Their crime? Shaving off the beard - considered a symbol of a man's faith and devotion in the Amish religion - of a bishop who was trying to retrieve a sect member in Los Angeles whom he thought was being kept against her will. Meanwhile, Scarlet and Ben plan a recommitment ceremony and Keegan uses a helpful transportation app called "Joyride," on which he meets driver Brooke Alexander (guest star Alexandra Breckenridge), a slightly overeducated, sports-betting girl who seems too good to be true.
