Kimmy and Stephanie have an epic surprise planned for DJ's 39th birthday, but Max cooks up a painful twist that changes everything.
Kimmy buys concert tickets for New Kids on the Block for DJ's 39th birthday, but when she and Stephanie discover that the tickets are counterfeit, they attempt to make it up to DJ by bringing the band to the house. Meanwhile, Fernando, Matt, Steve, and Max all believe that each of their birthday presents for DJ outrank the others.