Spoilers! Dive into OMITB S5 E9's plot & see how Meryl Streep, Paul Rudd & more A-listers shine in the show's incredible ensemble cast.
- October 25, 2025
AceShowbiz - Spoiler Alert: This article contains significant plot details for Only Murders in the Building Season 5, Episode 9.
The acclaimed series Only Murders in the Building consistently boasts one of television's most impressive ensemble casts. Beyond its beloved central trio, the show has a remarkable track record of attracting A-list talent, including Oscar winners like Meryl Streep, who continues her compelling role in Season 5. This season also sees the return of fan-favorite Paul Rudd, who lends his voice to the robot doorman L.E.S.T.R. and makes a quiet appearance. From musicians like Sting in earlier seasons to a parade of celebrated actors, the series truly offers an eclectic mix of talent.
Season 5 continues this tradition, featuring an array of guest stars who beautifully complement the main characters, serving as the essential glue for each season's narrative. The central mystery this season revolves around the beloved doorman, Lester (portrayed by Teddy Coluca and Emory Cohen in flashbacks), who becomes the victim. We are also introduced to his quirky wife, Lorraine, played by the esteemed Dianne Wiest. The plot thickens with a second victim, Nicky Caccimelio (Bobby Cannavale), alongside his wife Sofia (Téa Leoni). Notable appearances include Keegan-Michael Key as the mayor, and the return of Nathan Lane and James Caverly reprising their roles as Teddy Dimas Sr. and Jr., respectively. Amidst such a star-studded lineup, certain characters in Only Murders in the Building manage to shine exceptionally bright.
Among these standout performances is Randall, played by Jermaine Fowler. As the Arconia’s new doorman, Randall was undergoing training with Lester just prior to his untimely death. He was being groomed to take over the position, but Lester, ever protective, deliberately shielded Randall from the building’s secret casino and its association with Nicky. Lester’s intention was clear: he did not want the young man to suffer the same tragic fate that he ultimately met, highlighting a poignant layer to their brief but impactful relationship.