When Josh struggles to connect with his father Sam, Gabi tries to bring them together by inviting Sam to watch Josh play on Elliot’s softball team.
Josh tries to bond with his dad Matt (guest star Andy Buckley, "The Office"), but they have trouble finding common ground. When Matt decides to head out of town again, Gabi intervenes and brings Matt to Josh's softball game in an effort to get them together. But Josh is filling in on Elliot's team in a gay softball league, so Matt gets the wrong idea about his son.
When Matt goes out of his way to show his support, Josh is reluctant to tell the truth, wanting to hold on to his newfound relationship with his dad. Meanwhile, Yolanda recruits Sofia to help sell Squirrel Ranger cookies so they can win a cruise.
