With some prodding from Louis, Joe goes through a box of Ali's personal affects and finds a racy photo of her with Derek Jeter in Las Vegas. Joe tells Louis that Ali slept with Derek Jeter, which Louis then shares with Wyatt, and he accidentally blurts it out during an intense game of Celebrity between the couples. Ali is furious with Joe for not being able to keep any of their personal secrets from Louis. Joe eventually convinces her that he needs to share information that makes him feel insecure with Louis, and that he'll work on keeping certain things just between the two of them. Meanwhile, Wyatt gets nervous during Celebrity and misses a bunch of questions because Louis is too competitive. Once he and Joe pair up, he relaxes and does much better at the game.
