The inmates go all out to make an impression on some "Scared Straight" youth. Piper mocks Pennsatucky's new crusade. A rash decision by Pornstache has unintended consequences.
When Cesar goes by Bennett's apartment and asks how and where the baby will live, Bennett learns that Daya is pregnant. He is concerned that the system will discover he had sex with Daya, which could result in disciplinary action for both. He explains that his prosthetic left leg, originally thought to be from his tour in Afghanistan, is really from an infection when he had a cut and stepped into a dirty hot tub in Florida. Flashbacks reveal what Alex and Polly are looking for in a spouse, and depict Chapman meeting Larry. Baptiste visits Miss Claudette. Tricked by Watson and egged on by others, Pennsatucky starts a faith healing crusade. Scared straight arrives at the prison, and the inmates attempt to intimidate the visiting juvenile delinquents; however, the inmates have difficulty intimidating Dina, who robbed a liquor store from her wheelchair.
Piper succeeds by telling Dina the scariest part of prison is not other people, rather coming face to face with "who you really are." Pennsatucky's faith healing crusade ends after she attempts to heal Dina by forcefully removing her from the wheelchair, after which Pennsatucky is confined to the psychiatric ward. Flashbacks depict Tricia's life on the streets of New York City; she often shoplifts but keeps a list of what she steals so she can pay everyone back. She struggles to "make things square with Red." Mendez manipulates Tricia into selling illegal drugs.
When the tour with juvenile delinquents begins, Mendez notices the state she is in, and locks Tricia in a closet to prevent her from revealing she is holding the drugs. When he returns to release her, he finds that she has taken the drugs, overdosed and died. Fearing he will be found out, Mendez manipulates the scene to make it look like a suicide hanging. Nicky and Red blame themselves for Tricia's death, and both resolve to bring Mendez down.
