In an effort to keep her cheerleaders from fighting over the same guys, Brooke (Sophia Bush) devises a "Fantasy Boy Draft." Haley (Bethany Joy Lenz) and Peyton (Hilarie Burton) butt heads over Nathan (James Lafferty), while Lucas (Chad Michael Murray) has trouble keeping up with the brutal pace of basketball practice. Meanwhile, as the election nears, mayoral candidate Dan (Paul Johansson) clashes with his new opponent.