Carrie Underwood faces boos on American Idol after critiquing a contestant's original song. See her confident, unapologetic response to the audience.
- March 15, 2026
AceShowbiz - Carrie Underwood, the renowned country singer and judge on American Idol, responded with confidence after facing boos from the audience during a recent episode. The moment took place during the March 2 broadcast titled "Hollywood Week in Music City - Part 2," where Underwood critiqued a contestant's decision to perform an original song.
Before delivering her critique, Underwood anticipated the crowd's reaction, telling them, "I feel you guys are gonna boo me." When the boos began, she calmly addressed the audience, stating, "You're not included in the discussion." Her unapologetic stance quickly became a talking point among viewers and fans of the show.
The incident occurred as Underwood evaluated a contestant named Mor, who chose to showcase an original composition rather than a cover. The audience's disapproval appeared to stem from this unconventional choice, which Underwood challenged during her feedback.
Adding support, fellow country artist and American Idol judge Luke BryanLuke Bryan reminded the crowd of Underwood’s credibility, pointing out that she "only won this," referencing her victory in season four of the competition. Underwood joined the judging panel last year, replacing Katy Perry after her seven-season tenure.
The booing incident is not the first time Underwood has faced criticism related to her public appearances. Notably, two months prior to joining the American Idol panel in 2025, she performed "America the Beautiful" at President Donald Trump's inauguration. That performance sparked backlash from some fans and political opponents alike. A fan page on X, formerly dedicated to Underwood, rebranded itself to support Megan Moroney, sharing sentiments that Underwood had "disappointed the entire generation z."
Despite this, Underwood has largely remained quiet about the inauguration backlash. In an interview with The Independent before the event, she expressed her feelings by saying she "loves our country and was honored to have been asked to sing at the inauguration."
The American Idol season continues to draw attention, with the next episode scheduled to air on Monday, March 9, at 8 p.m. on ABC. It will also be available for streaming on Hulu the following day.
Underwood’s reaction to the boos highlights her resilience and confidence as she navigates the pressures of judging on a high-profile talent competition. Fans and critics alike will surely be watching closely as the season progresses.