When Ida (Eliza Coupe) unexpectedly shows up at her sister's house in tears, the staid Alison (Mary Elizabeth Ellis) bargains her way out of mom duty for the night and the two head off to a wine bar. There they run into Will (Demetri Martin) and the freshly divorced, sweat pants-clad Clark (Kyle Bornheimer). After some slightly inebriated commiserating about mismanaged marriages and other adult concerns, the foursome head out into the night, determined to prove they still have what it takes to have a good time.