It is Lily's birthday, and she (and Marshall) make a huge deal out of it every year. She is counting on it just being the 5 of them for their dinner celebration, when once again; Ted turns up with a new girlfriend who "could be the one." Through a series of flashbacks inspired by photos we see all the special occasions Ted has "ruined" by bringing a stranger. However, in the end Lily is much more sympathetic to Ted as we learn he insisted Lily get in Marshall and Ted's first college roommate photo just a few weeks after they had started dating. In addition, it seems Barney, throughout the years and currently cannot take a bad picture. He looks exactly the same and perfect no matter what. On the other hand, Marshall can not take a good picture, looking awkward in every photo.
STAR
LEAD
LEAD
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
Selena Gomez and Demi Lovato reunite at a heartfelt Friendsgiving in LA, blending Disney nostalgia with a surprise Hollywood Bowl concert experience.
36 mins ago
Billie Jean King opens up about her trailblazing fight for equality, personal struggles, and lasting impact on women's sports in this revealing look at a tru...
2 days ago
Sam Claflin sheds his heartthrob image for darker, nuanced roles in period dramas and fantasy films, including his standout turn in Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol.
2 days ago
Cleopatra Entertainment will release 1242 Gateway to the West, starring Ray Stevenson in his final film role, on DVD and select digital platforms on December 15, 2026.
2 days ago
Fans now create custom birthday songs for their favorite stars, replacing costly billboards as AI makes music production cheap while personal fandom details remain the real work.
2 days ago