- CELEBRITY
- 09:25 AM, Apr 20
While this incarnation has visual flair and attitude, it is too modernby Claudia Puig [USA Today ]
This one feels somewhat 'elementary.'by Roger Moore [Orlando Weekly ]
Sherlock Holmes is complete poppycockby Peter Howell [Toronto Star ]
holds your attention even though there's never really anything at stakeReview rate : B- by Owen Gleiberman [Entertainment Weekly ]
for all its lush production values, "Sherlock Holmes" is not much more sophisticatedby Stephen Whitty [Newark Star-Ledger ]
feels both too complicated and too elementaryby Liam Lacey [Globe and Mail ]
brighter than many movies this seasonby Moira Macdonald [Seattle Times ]
Bottom line: Right star, wrong director, wrong scriptReview rate : D+ by Adam Graham [Detroit News ]
as both a thrill ride and a mystery flick, it's elementaryby Joe Williams [St. Louis Post-Dispatch ]
"Sherlock Holmes" is intermittently divertingby A.O. Scott [NY Times ]