Couples are coming together. Couples are splitting apart. There's Casey and Ashleigh best friends and sorority sisters since freshman year, now they're on the outs. Lack of support Casey for Ashleigh is the issue. But someone's waiting in the wings to show Ashleigh she can be a friend, and that someone is Rebecca.
Then there's Rusty and Jen Z. After 3 weeks of dating, Rusty used the L word and it wasn't lesbian. Jen Z. freaked and Rusty is feeling like he'll never get this girl thing right. Of course, Cappie had counseled him to steer clear of the L word, but Rusty well, Rusty's rusty at anything having to do with girls. Humiliated, he swears off women forever. That's when Cappie decides to make everything better by taking all of Kappa Tau out for a Lunch Buffet. It's there that Cappie confesses to Rusty that he's never gotten over Casey. And guess who ends up having to settle the $475 tab?
Someone else is suddenly hot for Casey even though he's pretty sure it's a sin. That would be Dale who's agreed to offer up his charity for at-risk kids to Zeta Beta Zeta so they can get their philanthropy hours in. ZBZ puts on a play and then, the big surprise Dale's band takes the floor and puts Jack Black to shame.
And, as in most plays, all's well that ends well. Ashleigh and Casey make up. Cappie goes back to being Cappie glad he ever was with Casey at all. And Rusty, well Rusty finally tells Jen he's happy to be with her but confused about what he's feeling. She's touched. Then they touch and the rest is history.