In this flashback episode from 2007, Princess Carolyn gets BoJack a job on another TV show after Horsin' Around with an acclaimed director. However, after multiple changes to the pilot (insisted by BoJack), the show flops. Mr. Peanutbutter, then married to Jessica Biel, meets Diane, who is working in a coffeehouse under the name "Blarn". Todd is dating a girl named Emily, whose father he fears is in the Mafia.