October 22, 2016  
Home > News > TV

'American Idol' Top 5 Performance Show Is Full of Surprises as Caleb Johnson Still Leads

May 1, 2014 (4:21 am) GMT
The remaining finalists sing two songs each selected by fans in the week where Alex Preston's musical inspiration, Jason Mraz, becomes a guest mentor.

The competition is getting intense as "" season 13 is getting closer to finals. On Wednesday night, April 30, the Top 5 were back onstage to sing two songs each which they picked from the options suggested by fans.

To get to know more after the contestants, the show revealed their celebrity crushes and some were lucky enough to get surprise visit from the stars. Alex Preston, meanwhile, got to have dinner with , who has been repeatedly mentioned as one of Alex Preston's idols and serves as a guest mentor this week. His celebrity crush also showed up to give him a hug.

Alex performed first that night, starting it off with "Sweater Weather" by . Jason offered some suggestions that improved his body language. While the judges didn't say any harsh words, they clearly expected more from him as said, "You could do this in your sleep," and "wouldn't have minded hearing a bit more soaring."

The 20-year-old didn't disappoint in his second performance, an unplugged take on 's "Say Something". "It was a beautiful performance," said , adding that "it is more powerful to me."

Caleb Johnson rocked out the stage with "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" by . It wasn't as good as his previous performances, but J.Lo said she got goosies. Harry complained about his tendency to look at the camera instead of the audience.

Caleb showed his true ability with a cover of Whitesnake's "Still of the Night". Keith and J.Lo gave him a standing ovation, with the former exclaiming, "Awesome!" J.Lo said "that was killer!" and Harry couldn't imagine hearing someone perform that song any better.

Jessica Meuse opted for "Human" by for her first song. She hit the high notes in the chorus and J.Lo felt the emotion she put in the performance. "When you tap into the feeling and the emotion of the song, something happens," the female judge commented.

Jess sang 's "Summertime Sadness" for her second performance, and Harry thought "that's a perfect song" for her. He further described it as "a perfect marriage of voice and song," but Keith and J.Lo complained about her physical connection.

Sam Woolf did "Sing" by . Before his performance, Sam's celebrity crush paid a surprise visit to give him his mic. Unfortunately, he failed in his attempt to be funky as Keith pointed out the song was tough and politely said, "You did as good a job as you could on that song." Harry praised his effort to do something completely different.

Sam's performance of 's "How to Save a Life" may not help a lot to save him either. Harry was bothered by "some pitch issues," but wished he heard more of a cry in his voice toward the end. J.Lo didn't like it at first, but thought he hit it in the end.

Jena Irene emerged as a strong competitor as Harry said, "You probably move more than the other, remaining competitors," after her performance of "My Body" by . J.Lo also praised her, "You sounded really good, as you always do on everything that you sing."

Jena went with 's "Valerie" for her second performance, but she wasn't up to the song. J.Lo said, "It felt kind of AC, older," while Harry said, "Nice job tonight." Keith loved her "killer" vocals.

Jena also teamed up with Alex and Sam for a group performance of ' "Best Day of My Life", while Caleb and Jessica sang "Beast of Burden" by together.


  1. Bob Dylan Called 'Arrogant' for Ignoring Nobel Prize Win
  2. 'Doctor Strange' Star Tilda Swinton Wants Her Own Marvel Movie
  3. Jay-Z Makes History as Nominee for 2017 Songwriters Hall of Fame
  4. Police Called to Larsa and Scottie Pippen's House Before Divorce Announcement
  5. Did Madonna Just Clap Back at Lady GaGa With This Meme?
  6. Leonardo DiCaprio to Play the Man Who Invented Rock and Roll in Sam Phillips Biopic
  7. Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie to Sell Their Chateau Miraval in France Amid Divorce
  8. Director Tim Miller Leaves 'Deadpool 2' Due to Creative Differences